Well, this is certainly...hard to decide.
Oct. 29th, 2003 04:36 pmSo I got back my 22 page superhero story from the teacher today. It's completely a wash. I told him I wanted him to look at it before he graded it, so I could maybe make it a little better, but he must have forgotten or something, so I got the full graded version. It got a B, which is better than some people got, but I was really hoping for at least an A-. Anyway, I don't really want to have to go in and fix it over and over again, so maybe it's for the best that it's graded and all, but still. And the comments he made on the back, they were completely all over the place. He said I have a great writing style, that I have all these awesome attributes, but at the same time the story completely failed on certain fronts. Half of his comments were completely contradictory. The very things that failed were also the exact things that made it work so well. The very things that made it great made it also made it suck. And apparently, the fact that it "focuses on superheroes (no matter how laughable)" blah blah blah. Apparently it's not plot driven enough, even though the thing he always harps on is character development, and making them believable.
One of the funniest moments was when he wrote, "This is representative of the whole text, which just seems *so* arbitrary. The irony, of course, is that the arbitrary humor is also YOUR single greatest asset."
Oh, and the grade part's great too. "Thus, the grade is something of a compromise position between real fractures in the story and very real writing talent."
And the real irony here is that just today he ended up discussing a piece we read that was fractured, which was what made it so great to him. It's just so annoying. I mean, I don't know whether to be happy or pissed. I'm so in the middle it's not even all that funny.
One of the funniest moments was when he wrote, "This is representative of the whole text, which just seems *so* arbitrary. The irony, of course, is that the arbitrary humor is also YOUR single greatest asset."
Oh, and the grade part's great too. "Thus, the grade is something of a compromise position between real fractures in the story and very real writing talent."
And the real irony here is that just today he ended up discussing a piece we read that was fractured, which was what made it so great to him. It's just so annoying. I mean, I don't know whether to be happy or pissed. I'm so in the middle it's not even all that funny.